Enfield Cabinet has kept its decision to consult on closing three schools after scrutiny sent it back. Officers must recheck the figures before it opens.

Updated 6 November, evening: the council has published Cabinet’s decision. Cabinet kept its 14 October decision, so the consultation on closing the three schools goes ahead, and officers must check and correct the figures first. Details below.

Cabinet’s decision

Cabinet met on Wednesday 4 November and agreed to:

  • keep its 14 October decision to start consulting on closing Bishop Stopford’s School, Starks Field Primary School and Suffolks Primary School, including consultation on “credible alternatives to closure”
  • require officers to validate, clarify and where necessary update the data in the Cabinet report, taking account of possible errors raised by scrutiny councillors and the schools, and to put any corrections into the consultation documents
  • note that the scrutiny committee will get further chances to examine the evidence and make recommendations after the consultation and before Cabinet makes a final decision, and that later Cabinet decisions can still be called in

The council published the decision sheet on 6 November. Eight Cabinet members were present: Councillors Alessandro Georgiou, Maria Alexandrou, Lee Chamberlain, James Hockney, Andy Milne, Elisa Morreale, Edward Smith and Andrew Thorp. (Enfield Council, Cabinet decision sheet, 4 November 2026)

How it got here

Enfield’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee sent the decision to consult on closing three schools back to Cabinet. At its meeting on Tuesday 3 November, the committee asked Cabinet to think again about whether the consultation material is ready.

It wanted Cabinet to look at two things in particular:

  • the accuracy of the data in the report
  • the reasons for choosing these three schools

(Enfield Council, Cabinet briefing report on KD6131 after the Overview and Scrutiny meeting, 4 November 2026)

The three schools are Bishop Stopford’s School, Starks Field Primary School and Suffolks Primary School. Cabinet agreed on 14 October to consult on closing them, and on alternatives to closure. We reported that decision at the time, and the call-in last week.

Officers told Cabinet to carry on

Cabinet met the next evening, Wednesday 4 November. The officers’ report in front of it recommended that Cabinet keep its original decision and let the consultation go ahead, and Cabinet did. (Enfield Council, Cabinet agenda, 4 November 2026)

The report asked Cabinet to do three things:

  • keep the 14 October decision to consult on closing all three schools, including the alternatives
  • require officers to check, clarify and where needed correct the figures in the report, including errors raised by scrutiny councillors and the schools, and put the corrections into the consultation papers
  • note that scrutiny councillors will get another chance to examine the evidence before any final decision

It also said the council is commissioning independent analysis of the consultation responses. That analysis would be reported alongside the results before Cabinet decides anything further.

The report says no school is being closed at this stage. The options in the consultation include smaller admission numbers, federation or amalgamation with another school, becoming an academy, sharing spare space with community uses, more specialist SEND places alongside a smaller mainstream school, and keeping things as they are.

What the headteachers told the committee

All three headteachers spoke at the meeting, according to the officers’ summary.

  • Tammy Day, Bishop Stopford’s, said the method for choosing schools was too narrow. In her view it gave too little weight to results, the school’s Ofsted judgement and the effect on vulnerable pupils.
  • Andrea Cassius, Suffolks Primary, called the process and evidence “fundamentally flawed”. She said parental preference figures miss pupils with SEND who are placed by other routes, and that admissions had risen since the school expanded its SEND provision.
  • Melissa Davis Olivick, Starks Field Primary, said current pupil numbers were lower than the report stated. She asked when families would hear about places elsewhere and who would be accountable.

Officers told the meeting the schools were picked by a viability assessment of capacity trends, parental demand and projected pupil numbers across every school. They said it was not a judgement on the quality of teaching, and did not rank schools by deficit, results or the share of pupils with SEND.

Officers asked Councillor Ian Barnes, who led the call-in, to list the errors he had raised. The report says he agreed to provide one.

The questions about fairness and timing

Committee members asked whether the outcome had been decided in advance, whether there had been political interference, and whether the process could face a judicial review.

They also asked whether the timetable was driving the decision. Officers said it was not. But they said other councils had warned them that once closure plans are public, pupil numbers can fall and staff can leave, making the schools more vulnerable. The council was advised to move “as efficiently as possible”.

The consultation will run for six weeks, the report says, rather than the four suggested in the government’s guidance.

What the call-in said about pupils with SEND

The councillors’ written reasons for the call-in set out figures they say Cabinet did not weigh properly. These are their figures, not the council’s. (Reasons for call-in, KD6131)

  • Bishop Stopford’s has about 134 pupils with SEND, and takes about 80 pupils a year who join mid-year.
  • Suffolks has 16 speech and language places and 20 Key Stage 1 autism places, which are full.
  • Suffolks opened 20 Key Stage 2 autism places in September 2026, with eight pupils enrolled so far.
  • The council consulted from 3 June to 3 July 2026 on adding 20 specialist SEND places at Suffolks, and approved it.

What it means for you

If your child is at one of the three schools, nothing has closed and no closure has been decided. Once the consultation has run, Cabinet would need another report before publishing any formal closure proposal, and there is a further legal objection period after that.

If you want to have your say, watch for the consultation opening. Cabinet has now confirmed it will go ahead. It runs for six weeks, with a public meeting at each school. The council has not yet published the opening date; we will publish the dates when it does.

If you think the figures about your school are wrong, the report commits officers to correcting errors raised by the schools before the consultation papers go out. The school’s headteacher or governors are the route to raise them.

School holidays are on our Enfield school term dates page, and pupil numbers for each school are in our report on the original Cabinet paper.